Carrot Ink vs. 123inkjets vs. InkGrabber: Comparison of Printer Ink & Toner Cartridges

Though many online ink cartridge sellers sell their products, finding the best quality ink for your printer is somewhat difficult. Here is a comparison report of three companies who sell printer and toner ink cartridges.

Among the three, at Carrot Ink, you can get quality ink for 30-70% less than that of the popular name brands. However it is not comparable with the quality of OEM cartridges. 123inkjets provides their ink cartridges for lower prices. Yet the customers feel that it is not of high quality. Though InkGrabber claims to save you up to 92% off retails prices, many customers complain that the quality is very poor. 

The prices of some products are compared for the three for your reference and you can observe the difference in their prices compared below:

Comparison of prices for some products:

Carrot Ink sells premium quality compatible and remanufactured inkjet cartridges. It offers free shipping on orders over $50.

Ideal for: Remanufactured inkjet cartridges

The products of the companies they sell: Canon, HP, Brother, Dell, Epson, Kodak etc.

Pros

• Highest quality ink
• Compatible with  most brands of printers
• Returns are very easy and can be done within 365 days of purchase for full refund
• Good customer service
• One year money back is guaranteed without any questions.
• Same day shipping for the orders placed by 4pm EST except on Fridays and holidays
• Live customer support

Cons

• The quality of photos is not as good as OEM cartridges

123inkjets is one of the topmost suppliers of printer ink cartridges and toner ink cartridges at discount rates.

Ideal for: printer ink cartridges, laser toners, ink and toner refill kits. It also sells high quality photo-printing paper

The products of the companies they sell: Canon, Dell, Brother, Apple, HP, IBM, Kodak etc.

Pros

• Provides free shipping on orders above $55
• One year product guarantee is offered by them, but the returned ink product must be 70% full.
• Hassle free return policy
• Great deals
• Secure shopping
• Good quality products
• Compatible cartridges
• Inexpensive

Cons

• Some customers feel that the ink is good for printing text but not suitable for pictures.

InkGrabber is a pioneer online seller of printer ink cartridges, toner cartridges and fax cartridges.

Ideal for: Remanufactured inkjets, refill kits and compatible inkjets

The products of the companies they sell: All major brands like Canon, Brother, HP, Epson, Kodak etc.

Pros

• Provides 10%off on orders over $55
• Free shipping over $75
• They offer coupons and discounts.
• Combo discount packs and bulk discounts are also available.
• Defective products are replaced within 365 days of purchase.
• If the customer is not satisfied with the product, he can return it within 90days of the purchase for full refund.
• Orders can be sent within three business days
• Lowest prices when compared to the other sellers in this list.

Cons

• Poor quality
• Poor customer services

Comparison report of three:

In this list, Carrot Ink stands at the first place due to its quality as per the opinions of the users. The company’s one year money refund policy without any questions and shipping on the same day make it a clear winner. 123inkjets occupies second place due to its customer service, and full refund policy within a year of purchase under certain conditions.  InkGrabber stood in the last place as many users claim that their product quality is poor. Moreover they are not refunding the full amount within 365 days like their competitors in this list. Yet their products can be bought at lowest prices among the three.